Jump to content

DMCA Shortcut Helps Movie Companies Cheaply Identify ‘Potential’ BitTorrent Pirates

Recommended Posts

Several movie companies have obtained a DMCA subpoena to identify 25 account holders whose IP-addresses were caught sharing pirated content. This is an effective shortcut without any oversight from a federal judge. It significantly reduces costs and legal hurdles to go after alleged pirates. However, this procedure is not undisputed.

Over the past decade, hundreds of thousands of people have been accused of sharing pirated content via BitTorrent.

File-sharing lawsuits are a common phenomenon in US courts as well. Hundreds of new cases are filed every year, with most targeting a single defendant per lawsuit.

Most of these cases follow a procedure that’s well defined. The copyright holder files a complaint and requests a subpoena from the court requiring an ISP to identify the account holder connected to the ‘infringing’ IP-address. This request is then reviewed by a judge, who may or may not sign off on it.

Several courts have grown skeptical of these cases over the years, with some requiring rightsholders to present “something more” than just an IP-address as evidence. Other courts don’t share these reservations, and pretty much all subpoenas are signed off by a judge.

DMCA Subpoena Shortcut

Although it may appear that the legal procedures surrounding these BitTorrent piracy cases are pretty much set in stone after a decade, Hawaii-based attorney Kerry Culpepper has had success with a ‘loophole’ approach recently.

Instead of filing a standard copyright infringement lawsuit, the attorney requested a DMCA subpoena on behalf of several movie companies. Through the subpoena, the companies asked Hawaii Telecom to identify the account holders behind 25 IP-addresses that allegedly shared “Hellboy,” “Angel Has Fallen,” The Hitman’s Bodyguard” and other movies via BitTorrent.

This approach is noteworthy because DMCA subpoenas don’t require oversight from a judge. If the paperwork is submitted properly, a court clerk can sign off on it without any hassle. That can sometimes happen within a day.

Speed is not the key issue here, of course. Using this shortcut also saves money and other resources. Filing a DMCA subpoena costs $49 while the fee for a traditional copyright complaint is $402. This is without the time that goes into other legal paperwork and court hearings.

RIAA Tried and Failed

The advantages for copyright holders are clear. That said, using DMCA subpoenas to identify alleged BitTorrent pirates is not without controversy.

The RIAA tried a similar tactic two decades ago but was stopped in court when ISPs objected. The ISPs argued that DMCA subpoenas are only valid when an Internet service stores or links to the infringing content, not when they merely pass on traffic.

In two separate rulings, the DC Circuit and Eighth Circuit appeals courts eventually concluded that DMCA subpoenas can’t be issued against ISPs that are mere conduits. This is because the “notifications” described in the DMCA could not be applied to “mere conduit” ISPs that don’t store infringing material. As such, DMCA subpoenas are not an option.

Clerk Signs Subpoena

Despite this legal background, the clerk at the federal court in Hawaii signed off on the request earlier this month. This means that the movie companies can request Hawaii Telecom to hand over the subscriber information.

This appears to conflict with earlier cases but the movie companies disagree. In fact, their attorney believes that there is sufficient reason to believe that DMCA subpoenas can be used against ISPs under certain conditions.

Culpepper notes that the Ninth Circuit Appeals Court, which Hawaii falls under, never ruled on the mere conduit issue in a case like this. Hence, it’s an open question. In fact, the attorney argues that more recent decisions suggest that the DMCA notifications are valid in this case.

In repeat infringer cases against ISPs such as Cox and Grande, courts have concluded that these providers have no right to a DMCA safe harbor because they failed to act on DMCA notifications. This suggests that these notices are valid and apply to conduit providers.

This is a clever argument that could hold up but it hasn’t been tested in court, as Hawaii Telecom didn’t object to the DMCA subpoena. Instead, the clerk signed off on the request without asking questions. So for now, this shortcut works.

This isn’t the first time that Culpepper has successfully obtained DMCA subpoenas to identify potential copyright infringers. The Hawaii federal court signed-off on four similar requests in 2019.

Culpepper declined to comment on his reason to choose this route, but we assume that costs play a major role. The personal information obtained through the subpoenas will likely be used to negotiate settlements with the infringers. And those who refuse to settle risk being taken to court in a proper lawsuit, of course.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Avoid unnecessary posts such as 'Thank you', 'Welcome', etc. Such posts will be deleted and user will be warned if it happens again. If caught spamming, the following actions are applicable -

  • First time - Warning
  • Second time - 5000 Points will be deducted
  • Third time - Ban for 7 days
  • Fourth time - Permanent Ban

If the post helped you, reward the user by reacting to the post like this -


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Similar Topics

    • Snake Eyes Featurette Reveals Behind-The-Scenes Look At G.I. Joe Movie

      Hot off the release of a new trailer, Snake Eyes: G.I. Joe Origins has released a new featurette taking fans behind the scenes. The film stars Henry Golding as the fan-favorite character Snake Eyes in a feature-length origin story that is set to reboot the G.I. Joe film franchise. At one point set to come out in October 2o21, Paramount bumped up the release date of the film to July 23, 2021. Now with only two months until Snake Eyes opens in theaters, the studio has started to ramp up the m

      in Movies & TV Shows

    • New In The Heights Clip Showcases Movie Musical's Impressive Cast

      A new clip from In the Heights highlights the movie's impressive cast. The upcoming film comes from director Jon M. Chu and is based on the musical of the same name by Quiara Alegría Hudes and Lin-Manuel Miranda. Set in New York City's Washington Heights, it follows bodega owner Usnavi de la Vega (Anthony Ramos) as he dreams for a better life. The original musical, which made its Broadway debut in 2008, won multiple Tonys and other prestigious awards. Many are eager to see how the beloved produc

      in Movies & TV Shows

    • Cinderella 2021 Movie Image Reveals First Look At Billy Porter As The Fairy Godmother

      A first look at Billy Porter as the Fairy Godmother from the upcoming Cinderella movie has just been revealed. Cinderella will be an Amazon Prime Original from writer-director, Kay Cannon, who wants to modernize the classic tale. The film will be a jukebox musical, using pop songs to fill out its soundtrack. Singer Camila Cabello will play the titular role with Nicholas Galitzine playing Prince Robert. Pose's Billy Porter will star as the iconic Fairy Godmother. Porter intends to reinvent t

      in Movies & TV Shows

    • Mary Elizabeth Winstead Is An Assassin In Kate Movie First Look Images

      Mary Elizabeth Winstead is an assassin in Kate movie first look images. Winstead portrayed the crossbow-wielding killer Huntress in Birds of Prey, and must’ve really enjoyed the experience of taking lives on screen, because she’s next set to star as an assassin Netflix’s Kate. But Kate is not in fact just a run of the mill assassin movie. The twist this time is that Winstead’s titular Kate learns while on a job in Tokyo that she has been injected with poison, giving her just 24 hours to liv

      in Movies & TV Shows

    • Fix “Windows Cannot Identify this Hardware” Code 9 Error

      Looking for ways to fix “Windows cannot identify this hardware” error on Windows 10? Well, also referred to as Code 9 in the technical domain, this error usually occurs when certain device drivers of specific hardware become outdated or corrupt. And due to this, Windows displays the following error when you check the device status properties of the hardware: FAQs: What is Code 9 error? As you can see in the above snapshot, Code 9 error is encountered when Windows is unable to iden

      in .::IH::. Torrent Guides and Tutorials

  • Who Viewed the Topic

    3 members have viewed this topic:
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.